How to Make the Perfect Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe lovers, you’re in for a melty, spicy, and savory treat. This Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe isn’t just another sandwich—it’s the ultimate comfort food with a bold, flavorful kick that transforms leftover chicken into a crave-worthy masterpiece. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch, a satisfying dinner, or a crowd-pleasing party snack, this sandwich delivers in under 20 minutes with minimal effort.

The inspiration for this recipe came on a lazy Sunday afternoon when I had some leftover rotisserie chicken, a few slices of bread, and an urge to make something exciting. A swirl of Frank’s Hot Sauce, a scoop of ranch dressing, and the magic of melted cheese later—I discovered the perfect grilled cheese upgrade.

In this article, you’ll discover everything you need to make this spicy comfort classic at home: from choosing the right cheeses to storing leftovers like a pro. We’ll also cover fun ways to customize your sandwich, answer popular questions like “Is buffalo sauce good with grilled cheese?”, and suggest some must-try variations.

Let’s turn your regular sandwich game up a notch with this irresistible Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe.

If you love spicy, creamy sandwiches, this Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe is perfect for you.

Why This Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe Is a Game-Changer

The Perfect Balance of Heat, Creaminess, and Crunch

The beauty of this Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe lies in its balance. The crispy, golden bread adds the crunch, the cheesy interior brings the gooey comfort, and the buffalo-spiced chicken gives it that tangy heat. It’s bold but comforting—perfect for those who love flavor without sacrificing simplicity.

The use of rotisserie or pre-cooked chicken cuts down on prep time while still delivering satisfying texture. The cream cheese and ranch dressing mellow out the spice, so it’s not overpowering—just addictively delicious.

Quick, Easy, and Totally Foolproof

This recipe is designed to be made in under 20 minutes, which makes it perfect for busy weeknights or lazy weekend lunches. You don’t need any fancy equipment—just a good skillet and some pantry staples.

You simply prep the cheesy spread, mix the chicken filling, assemble, and grill. That’s it. No complex steps. No need for special kitchen gadgets. And because it uses cooked chicken, it’s an excellent way to repurpose leftovers into something completely new and exciting.

Discover great ideas like Chicken Bacon Ranch Tater Tot Casserole to keep your quick meal game strong.

Family-Friendly and Highly Customizable

One of the best things about this grilled cheese recipe is how easily it adapts to different tastes. Don’t like blue cheese? Skip it. Want extra heat? Add more cayenne or a dash of sriracha. Feeding kids? Dial down the spice and toss in some cheddar.

It’s also a crowd-pleaser—serve it at game nights, casual get-togethers, or as a fun family dinner. You can even cut the sandwiches into quarters and serve them as sliders or appetizers.

How to Make the Perfect Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Sandwich

---

• Author: MARY
• Total Time: 20 minutes
• Yield: 4 sandwiches 1x

Print Recipe

Pin Recipe

Description

This Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe brings the bold, tangy flavor of buffalo wings into a crispy, creamy sandwich. Perfectly seasoned shredded chicken is mixed with hot sauce, ranch dressing, and garlic, then layered with a blend of melty cheeses and grilled to golden perfection. Ready in under 20 minutes, this spicy grilled cheese sandwich is a game-changer for quick lunches, easy weeknight dinners, or game-day snacks. It’s easy to make, completely customizable, and guaranteed to satisfy every time.

---

Ingredients

Scale 1x2x3x

Cheese Spread:

• 4 oz cream cheese, softened

• 4 tbsp crumbled blue cheese

• ½ tsp paprika

• ¼ tsp cayenne pepper (optional)

• 1 tsp ground black pepper

Buffalo Chicken Filling:

• 2 cups cooked chicken breast, shredded (rotisserie works great)

• ½ cup Frank’s RedHot sauce (or any buffalo hot sauce)

• ½ cup ranch dressing (store-bought or homemade)

• 2 tsp minced garlic

Sandwich Assembly:

• 8 slices sandwich bread (white, sourdough, or brioche)

• 4–8 slices Muenster cheese (or your favorite melting cheese)

• 4 tbsp butter (for spreading on bread)

Optional Add-ins:

• Diced avocado

• Chopped celery

• Sliced tomatoes

• Red onion

• Mozzarella, cheddar, or Monterey Jack cheese substitute

---

Instructions

1. Make the Cheese Spread:
   In a bowl, combine the cream cheese, blue cheese, paprika, cayenne (if using), and black pepper. Mix until smooth and creamy. Set aside.

2. Prepare the Buffalo Chicken Filling:
   In a second bowl, mix the shredded chicken with buffalo sauce, ranch dressing, and minced garlic. Stir until the chicken is well-coated and evenly combined.

3. Assemble the Sandwiches:
   Butter one side of each bread slice. Flip them over. On the unbuttered side of 4 slices, spread a generous layer of the cheese mixture. Top with about ½ cup of the buffalo chicken mixture. Add one or two slices of Muenster cheese on the other 4 slices of bread. Close the sandwiches with the buttered sides facing out.

4. Grill the Sandwiches:
   Heat a non-stick skillet over medium-low heat. Grill the sandwiches 4–5 minutes per side, pressing gently with a spatula, until golden brown and crispy. Work in batches if needed.

5. Serve:
   Let the sandwiches rest for 1 minute, then slice and serve warm. Optional: serve with ranch or extra buffalo sauce on the side.

Notes

• Leftover Storage:
  Wrap cooled sandwiches in foil and refrigerate for up to 2 days. Reheat in the oven at 350°F (still wrapped) for 10–15 minutes for best crispness.

• Cheese Swaps:
  Don’t like blue cheese? Use cheddar, Monterey Jack, or Colby Jack. Want extra heat? Add jalapeños or more cayenne to the chicken.

• Make Ahead Tip:
  Prepare the buffalo chicken and cheese spread a day in advance to cut down on prep time. Store each in an airtight container in the fridge.

• Vegetarian Option:
  Swap chicken for buffalo tofu or jackfruit to keep it meat-free.

• Prep Time: 10 minutes
• Cook Time: 10 minutes
• Category: Lunch, Dinner, Sandwiches, Comfort Food
• Cuisine: American, Game Day, Spicy Recipes

Nutrition

• Calories: ~620 kcal
• Sugar: 3g
• Sodium: 1,150mg
• Fat: 37g
• Saturated Fat: 15g
• Carbohydrates: 28g
• Fiber: 2g
• Protein: 32g
• Cholesterol: 105mg

Essential Ingredients That Make This Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe Perfect

The Backbone: Buffalo Chicken Mixture

At the heart of this Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe is the bold, zesty chicken mixture. You’ll start with cooked shredded chicken—rotisserie chicken works wonders here—and combine it with Frank’s RedHot Sauce, ranch dressing, and minced garlic. This combo packs the signature buffalo kick, with enough creaminess to mellow the heat.

Want to dial it up? A pinch of cayenne pepper or some crushed red chili flakes will do the trick. Prefer a little less fire? Cut back on the hot sauce and add a splash more ranch. The spice level is all yours to control.

Here’s a breakdown of the chicken mix:

The Cheese Layer: Gooey, Creamy, Bold

Every grilled cheese lives or dies by its cheese. And this buffalo grilled cheese sandwich takes it to the next level with a blend of:

• Cream Cheese – soft, tangy, and rich, it binds the flavors together
• Crumbled Blue Cheese – gives that classic buffalo flavor (optional)
• Sliced Muenster Cheese – for perfect melt and stretch
• Alternative Cheese Options – White cheddar, Colby Jack, Monterey Jack, or Mozzarella

Not into blue cheese? No problem—you can leave it out or reduce the amount. This sandwich is totally customizable. Just be sure to use a good melting cheese so that it oozes perfectly between the crispy bread.

Bread and Butter: The Foundation

Let’s not forget the bread. Sandwich bread, when buttered and grilled low and slow, gives you that iconic grilled cheese texture: crunchy on the outside, soft and steamy inside. You can use sourdough, white bread, or even brioche if you’re feeling indulgent.

Each slice is buttered on one side and layered with the cheese spread and buffalo chicken filling on the other. Grill it slowly to avoid burning the bread before the cheese melts.

Why These Ingredients Work Together

This Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe nails flavor layering:

• The heat from the buffalo sauce wakes up your taste buds.
• The ranch and cream cheese cool things down and add smoothness.
• The blue cheese adds punchy depth.
• The buttered bread adds crunch and richness to each bite.

It’s not just a sandwich—it’s an experience that hits all the notes: spicy, creamy, cheesy, and crispy.

Step-by-Step Instructions for the Ultimate Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe

Step 1: Mix the Buffalo Chicken Filling

To start this Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe, grab a mixing bowl. Add your cooked shredded chicken, Frank’s Hot Sauce, ranch dressing, and minced garlic. Stir until every bite of chicken is fully coated. You want it creamy, spicy, and savory—this will be the bold heart of your sandwich.

For best results, use chicken that’s already tender—rotisserie or leftover grilled chicken works perfectly. This also saves time and keeps the prep under 20 minutes.

Step 2: Make the Creamy Cheese Spread

In a second bowl, mash together softened cream cheese, crumbled blue cheese, black pepper, paprika, and optional cayenne pepper. This creates the rich, cheesy base that perfectly complements the buffalo heat.

Tip: Let the cream cheese sit at room temperature for 10 minutes to make mixing easier.

This cheese spread does two things:

• Keeps the sandwich creamy and gooey inside
• Adds a sharp contrast to the tangy hot sauce

This is what makes your buffalo grilled cheese sandwich stand out from the average melt.

Step 3: Assemble the Sandwich

Lay out your 8 slices of sandwich bread. Butter one side of each slice—this will be the outer crust that crisps up when grilled. Flip them over, and on the unbuttered side, spread a thick layer of the cheese mixture on 4 slices.

Next, spoon about ½ cup of the buffalo chicken filling on top of each cheese-spread slice. Try to spread it evenly for consistent bites. On the remaining 4 slices, place 1 to 2 slices of Muenster cheese (or your favorite melty variety), and close the sandwich.

Optional twist: Sprinkle in diced celery or chopped avocado if you want a creamy crunch!

Step 4: Grill to Perfection

Heat a skillet over low to medium heat and spray it lightly with cooking spray or a small dab of butter. Place your sandwiches in the skillet (in batches if needed). Grill for 4–5 minutes per side, or until golden brown and crispy.

Pro tip: Press lightly with a spatula to help the cheese melt and the flavors bind.

Once the sandwiches are golden and the cheese is oozing out, remove from the pan and let them cool for a minute or two. This lets the inside set slightly without burning your mouth.

Step 5: Serve and Enjoy

Cut the sandwich in half, serve with a side of extra buffalo sauce, ranch, or blue cheese dressing for dipping. Pair it with fries, a salad, or celery sticks for a full meal.

This Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe will be a hit at dinner tables, tailgates, or late-night snack sessions. It’s that kind of sandwich—the one you think about long after it’s gone.

Easy Variations to Customize Your Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe

Make It Spicier or Milder

One of the best things about this Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe is how easily you can adapt the heat level to your liking. If you’re a spice lover, add a splash of extra hot sauce, a pinch of ghost pepper powder, or sliced jalapeños directly into the chicken mixture. You’ll get that fiery kick with every bite.

Prefer a milder sandwich? Reduce the hot sauce by half and increase the ranch dressing or add a spoonful of sour cream. You’ll still get the buffalo flavor, but without the heat punch.

Swap the Cheese, Not the Flavor

Not everyone’s a fan of blue cheese, and that’s okay. This spicy grilled cheese is flexible when it comes to your cheese choices. Try these great swaps that still melt beautifully and complement the buffalo chicken:

Just make sure your cheeses are high-moisture and meltable—you want that iconic cheese pull every time you slice into your buffalo grilled cheese sandwich.

Add Veggies for Crunch and Freshness

Want to make your Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe a bit healthier or more colorful? Toss in some diced celery, chopped green onions, or mashed avocado. These add-ons not only balance the richness of the cheese but also add texture and nutrients.

Here are a few ideas:

• Mashed avocado: Creamy and cool—spread it under the cheese layer
• Diced tomatoes: Juicy and acidic—mix it with the chicken
• Chopped celery: Classic buffalo pairing—adds crunch
• Red onions: Sharp bite and color pop

Go Big With Bread Upgrades

Your bread matters—a lot. While basic sandwich bread gets the job done, upgrading to Texas toast, sourdough, or brioche turns your grilled cheese into a gourmet experience.

Each bread offers a slightly different texture:

Brush your bread with garlic butter or even a touch of honey butter for an extra flavor punch. It’s all about elevating the basics into something crave-worthy.

Tips and Tricks for a Perfect Grilled Cheese Every Time

Use Low Heat for Even Crisping

When making this Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe, it’s tempting to crank the heat to get that quick crust. Don’t. A medium-low flame is your best friend. It gives the cheese time to melt fully while the bread crisps up to a golden brown without burning.

If your pan is too hot, the bread will brown (or burn) before the cheese inside melts—leaving you with a sandwich that’s crispy outside and cold in the middle.

Pro tip: Cover the pan loosely with a lid to help trap heat and melt the cheese faster.

Don’t Skimp on Butter

That golden, toasted finish? It comes from using real butter on the outer sides of the bread slices. Spread it edge to edge, and make sure it’s room temperature so it spreads smoothly.

Alternatively, try:

• Garlic herb butter for an added punch
• Mayonnaise as a spread—it browns beautifully and adds tang

Whatever your choice, this step is crucial to nailing the classic grilled cheese crust in your buffalo chicken grilled cheese sandwich.

Load It Right

Don’t overload your sandwich with too much filling. Stick to about ½ cup of buffalo chicken per sandwich. Too much filling can make the sandwich difficult to flip, and the insides may spill out.

Layering tip:

1. Cream cheese spread first
2. Buffalo chicken mixture second
3. Sliced cheese on top
4. Close with buttered bread and press lightly

This method locks in flavor and structure for the best version of your Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe.

Check out Chicken Avocado Wrap Recipe for another delicious and neatly packed sandwich idea.

Grill in Batches If Needed

If you’re making more than one or two sandwiches, work in batches. Don’t overcrowd your skillet—it reduces the heat and causes uneven browning. Keep cooked sandwiches warm in a 200°F oven while you finish grilling the rest.

It’s also a good idea to clean the skillet with a paper towel between batches to prevent burnt crumbs or old butter from affecting the next round.

Let It Rest Before Serving

Once your grilled cheese is done, give it a moment before slicing in. This allows the cheese to set slightly and makes cutting cleaner, especially for a sandwich packed with gooey fillings like this one.

Serve with:

• Extra buffalo sauce for dipping
• Ranch or blue cheese dressing on the side
• Celery sticks for a crunch contrast

This isn’t just a sandwich—it’s a flavor-packed comfort food that always delivers. And following these tips ensures your Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe turns out perfect every single time.

How to Store and Reheat Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe

The Best Way to Store Leftovers

You’ve mastered the Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe and have a few sandwiches left over—now what? Storing them properly is key to keeping the bread crisp and the filling flavorful.

Here’s what to do:

• Wrap each sandwich in foil individually—this helps prevent moisture from making the bread soggy.
• Store in the fridge for up to 2 days. While it’s best eaten fresh, this sandwich actually holds up well if stored right.

Avoid using plastic wrap or airtight containers, as they trap steam and make the crust soft.

How to Reheat for Maximum Crunch

To enjoy your buffalo chicken grilled cheese sandwich the next day, reheating it correctly matters just as much as cooking it. Don’t just nuke it in the microwave—unless you want limp bread.

Here are three effective methods:

1. Oven Reheat (Best Overall)

• Leave the sandwich in the foil
• Place on a baking sheet
• Bake at 350°F for 10–15 minutes
  This warms the inside evenly and re-crisps the bread.

2. Skillet Reheat (Fast and Tasty)

• Heat a non-stick pan over low heat
• Add the sandwich (unwrapped), press with a spatula
• Cook for 2–3 minutes per side
  This restores the original crunch and melts the cheese again perfectly.

3. Microwave (Last Resort)

• Wrap sandwich in a paper towel
• Heat on medium power for 30–45 seconds
  Bread will be soft, but the inside will warm. Not ideal, but quick.

Pro Tips for Next-Day Success

Want your Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe to taste just as good tomorrow?

Try these hacks:

• Toast the bread slightly before assembling—gives a stronger foundation
• Avoid overfilling—makes reheating easier and less messy
• Pack sauces separately—serve them fresh on the side after reheating

And if you’ve made a big batch, consider freezing the ungrilled sandwiches (just the assembled version) and cooking them later fresh.

With the right storage and reheating method, your Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe stays just as crispy, creamy, and flavorful the second time around.

FAQ – Your Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe Questions Answered

Don’t miss our Quick Cheesy Chicken Wrap if you’re looking for another melty, cheese-loaded favorite.

Serving Ideas and What to Pair with Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe

Classic Sides That Make the Meal

The Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe is bold and hearty on its own, but pairing it with the right sides can elevate it into a full-blown meal. You don’t need anything complicated—just simple sides that balance its spicy, cheesy richness.

Top go-to classics include:

• French fries or sweet potato fries: Crunchy and salty to match the creamy, spicy sandwich
• Coleslaw: Creamy or vinegar-based—great for cooling the heat
• Tomato soup: A grilled cheese staple, even with buffalo flair
• Pickles: Sharp and tangy, they cut right through the richness

For a fun twist, try adding a few celery sticks on the side with ranch or blue cheese dip—just like traditional buffalo wings.

Light and Fresh Pairings

If you want to keep things a little lighter, balance this buffalo grilled cheese sandwich with a crisp, fresh salad. The heat and cheese of the sandwich pair perfectly with greens.

Here are some easy salad ideas:

• Chopped romaine with ranch and bacon bits
• Spinach salad with sliced strawberries and feta
• Avocado tomato salad with olive oil and lime

Adding fresh veggies helps lighten up the meal and add nutrients without losing the bold flavors that define the Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe.

Dips and Drizzles

To make this sandwich extra exciting, serve it with dipping sauces or light drizzles:

You can also drizzle buffalo sauce on top of the sandwich or serve it open-faced with toppings for a different presentation.

Beverages That Work

Since the Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe has strong, spicy notes, pair it with drinks that balance or cool those flavors. Try:

• Iced sweet tea
• Lemonade
• Light beer or cider
• Sparkling water with lime

These options refresh your palate and round out the meal.

Whether you’re serving it with fries, salad, or a cold drink, the Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe delivers big flavor—and with the right pairing, it becomes a full dining experience.

Nutrition Facts and Dietary Tips for This Spicy Sandwich

What’s Inside the Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe?

The Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe may be indulgent, but when enjoyed in moderation or tweaked slightly, it can absolutely fit into a balanced diet. It’s a comfort food favorite with bold flavors, and knowing what you’re eating helps you make smarter choices.

Here’s a rough nutrition breakdown per sandwich (based on standard ingredients and portions):

Keep in mind: These numbers can vary depending on the type of bread, cheese, and dressing used.

How to Make It Lighter Without Sacrificing Flavor

You don’t have to skip the Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe to eat healthier—you just need to make a few smart swaps:

• Use low-fat cream cheese and mozzarella instead of full-fat versions
• Swap out buttered bread for whole grain or sprouted grain bread
• Use Greek yogurt ranch dressing for lower fat and higher protein
• Choose rotisserie breast meat for a leaner protein base
• Grill using olive oil spray instead of butter for a heart-healthier option

Even small changes can cut 100–150 calories per sandwich without losing the spicy, creamy, cheesy flavor you crave in a buffalo grilled cheese sandwich.

Can This Recipe Fit Special Diets?

With a few adjustments, yes. Here’s how:

This flexibility makes the Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe great for households with mixed dietary needs. You can prep the base, then tweak each sandwich based on who’s eating it.

Final Tip: Portion Control Is Key

While this spicy grilled cheese recipe is incredibly satisfying, it’s also rich. If you’re watching your intake, consider cutting your sandwich in half and pairing it with a big salad or broth-based soup. You’ll still enjoy the flavor without overdoing the calories.

With some simple ingredient swaps and thoughtful pairings, the Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe can be a flavorful, crave-worthy part of your menu—even on a health-conscious plan.

Conclusion: Make This Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe Your Go-To Comfort Fix

There’s something undeniably satisfying about biting into a hot, crispy, cheesy sandwich—and this Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe is that experience dialed up to 100. It’s spicy, creamy, and crunchy all in one. Whether you’re repurposing leftover chicken or making it fresh, this recipe is fast, flexible, and absolutely crave-worthy.

You can stick with the classic or personalize it with different cheeses, breads, and veggie add-ins. It stores well, reheats beautifully, and works for lunch, dinner, or a late-night comfort fix.

Looking for inspiration? Try our Baked Ham and Cheese Croissants if you want another warm, melty sandwich idea with a slightly sweet twist.

Now that you’ve got all the steps, tips, and variations in hand, go ahead—get that skillet ready and make this Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe your new grilled cheese favorite.

Save or print this Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe so it’s always on hand when the cravings hit!

👉 Enjoyed this Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe? Discover more tasty ideas by following us on Facebook for daily kitchen inspiration and helpful cooking tips. Don’t forget to explore our Pinterest boards packed with delicious recipes, seasonal favorites, and meal planning ideas. Let’s cook something amazing together!